{"schema_version":"GreyResearchObject 1.2","id":"GSX:SRD-002","slug":"the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant","series_slug":"r350-counterfactual","series_title":"The R350 Counterfactual","series_number":"03","paper_number":"02","title":"The Welfare Cost of Not Paying the Grant","version":"1.0","status":"published","primary_question":"What poverty, consumption, and social costs does the industrialisation counterfactual leave out when the grant is not paid?","summary":"The poverty, consumption and social cost omitted from the industrialisation counterfactual.","topics":["grants","fiscal-policy","south-africa"],"geographies":["South Africa"],"keywords":["Social grants","Fiscal policy","South Africa","welfare","cost","paying","grant","poverty","consumption","social","costs","industrialisation","counterfactual","leave","out","paid"],"related_questions":["What is the welfare cost of withholding the SRD grant?","Which social costs sit outside a productive-capital account of the grant budget?"],"answer":{"conditional_answer":"Withholding the SRD envelope has a central explicit welfare cost of R426.9 billion in welfare-equivalent 2026 rand, about R1.68 of social cost for every R1 withheld. The scenario range is R237 billion to R743 billion.","evidence_status":"modelled","assumption_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:A01","GSX:SRD-002:A02","GSX:SRD-002:A03"],"result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"main_limitation":"This is not a Treasury invoice, a forecast or a confidence interval. Crime, unrest and household dissolution are left outside the priced total. The central case is an analytical benchmark.","sensitivity":"high"},"entities":["South Africa","grants","fiscal-policy","south-africa"],"methods":[{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:M01","name":"Welfare-cost ledger","model_class":"welfare counterfactual","purpose":"The model prices the explicit welfare cost of withholding the same SRD envelope valued in the industrial-fund paper. It combines consumption, costly credit, scarring and labour effects and keeps the local spending multiplier out of the welfare total.","implementation_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model.py"}],"parameters":[{"id":"P01","name":"Same envelope","symbol":"see the manuscript","description":"The withheld resource is about R253.5 billion in constant 2026 purchasing power, the same base as the industrial-fund paper.","value":"253.5","unit":"billion constant 2026 rand","price_year":"2026","scenario_values":{"central":"253.5"},"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]}],"equations":["The manuscript states the accounting identities in prose. No separate machine equation list is published."],"scenarios":[{"id":"S01","name":"Central welfare case","role":"baseline","description":"The explicit welfare-equivalent cost of withholding the envelope is between R237 billion and R743 billion. The central estimate is R426.9 billion, about R1.68 of social cost for every R1 withheld.","assumption_overrides":{"note":"The central scenario uses the registered assumptions."},"probability_status":"illustrative","probability":"not assigned","rationale":"The manuscript labels this as a scenario."}],"unresolved_questions":["What poverty, consumption, and social costs does the industrialisation counterfactual leave out when the grant is not paid?"],"research_type":"counterfactual","evidence_status":"modelled","peer_review_status":"none","external_review_status":"none","ai_assistance":{"disclosure":"GreyScienx manuscripts are prepared with substantial AI assistance in research, drafting, and computation. This record is not peer-reviewed. The published manuscript does not itemise AI participation by activity.","itemised":false},"date_modified":"2026-09-28","date_note":"Date of this machine record. It is not a separately catalogued manuscript issue date.","authors":[{"name":"Pakang Senosha","affiliation":"University of Pretoria","slug":"pakang-senosha"}],"extraction_status":"full_text_claim_led","manuscript":{"study_id":"GSX:SRD-002","source_path":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/report.md","source_sha256":"fb1ca8cc364a1015007b8e422effa14fb20d4f6cfbd4487fbd550b5d805ef487","source_bytes":48422,"character_count":48386,"word_count":6829,"headings":[{"level":1,"title":"The Welfare Cost of Not Paying the Grant","slug":"the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant","line":1},{"level":2,"title":"What South Africa would have asked poor households to surrender in the R350 industrialisation counterfactual","slug":"what-south-africa-would-have-asked-poor-households-to-surrender-in-the-r350-industrialisation-counterfactual","line":3},{"level":1,"title":"PART I: The result in one sitting","slug":"part-i-the-result-in-one-sitting","line":5},{"level":2,"title":"The short answer","slug":"the-short-answer","line":7},{"level":2,"title":"The headline ledger","slug":"the-headline-ledger","line":19},{"level":2,"title":"Why a rand is not always a rand","slug":"why-a-rand-is-not-always-a-rand","line":36},{"level":2,"title":"What the model does not claim","slug":"what-the-model-does-not-claim","line":44},{"level":1,"title":"PART II: The grant at household scale","slug":"part-ii-the-grant-at-household-scale","line":54},{"level":2,"title":"Small nationally, consequential at the margin","slug":"small-nationally-consequential-at-the-margin","line":56},{"level":2,"title":"An individual grant enters a shared household","slug":"an-individual-grant-enters-a-shared-household","line":68},{"level":2,"title":"What the money was used for","slug":"what-the-money-was-used-for","line":80},{"level":2,"title":"The consumption counterfactual","slug":"the-consumption-counterfactual","line":88},{"level":1,"title":"PART III: From the household to the local economy","slug":"part-iii-from-the-household-to-the-local-economy","line":96},{"level":2,"title":"The township multiplier is a circulation story","slug":"the-township-multiplier-is-a-circulation-story","line":98},{"level":2,"title":"Why losing demand can destroy more than sales","slug":"why-losing-demand-can-destroy-more-than-sales","line":110},{"level":2,"title":"Spatial incidence","slug":"spatial-incidence","line":116},{"level":2,"title":"Informal borrowing is not an equal substitute","slug":"informal-borrowing-is-not-an-equal-substitute","line":122},{"level":1,"title":"PART IV: Poverty and food security","slug":"part-iv-poverty-and-food-security","line":132},{"level":2,"title":"The evidence is strongest during the pandemic shock","slug":"the-evidence-is-strongest-during-the-pandemic-shock","line":134},{"level":2,"title":"Food insecurity before relief","slug":"food-insecurity-before-relief","line":146},{"level":2,"title":"Short hardship can become long damage","slug":"short-hardship-can-become-long-damage","line":152},{"level":2,"title":"Children are indirect recipients","slug":"children-are-indirect-recipients","line":160},{"level":1,"title":"PART V: Work, search and the dignity question","slug":"part-v-work-search-and-the-dignity-question","line":170},{"level":2,"title":"Cash can support labour-market participation","slug":"cash-can-support-labour-market-participation","line":172},{"level":2,"title":"The model prices labour cautiously","slug":"the-model-prices-labour-cautiously","line":182},{"level":2,"title":"Participation beyond recorded search","slug":"participation-beyond-recorded-search","line":188},{"level":1,"title":"PART VI: The explicit welfare price","slug":"part-vi-the-explicit-welfare-price","line":196},{"level":2,"title":"Four priced components","slug":"four-priced-components","line":198},{"level":2,"title":"The cost arrives before the return","slug":"the-cost-arrives-before-the-return","line":221},{"level":2,"title":"What remains outside the number","slug":"what-remains-outside-the-number","line":233},{"level":1,"title":"PART VII: Paper 1 meets Paper 2","slug":"part-vii-paper-1-meets-paper-2","line":250},{"level":2,"title":"Factories now face a hurdle rate","slug":"factories-now-face-a-hurdle-rate","line":252},{"level":2,"title":"National gain is not personal compensation","slug":"national-gain-is-not-personal-compensation","line":264},{"level":2,"title":"Can later industrial employment compensate recipients?","slug":"can-later-industrial-employment-compensate-recipients","line":276},{"level":2,"title":"The better counterfactual is rarely all-or-nothing","slug":"the-better-counterfactual-is-rarely-all-or-nothing","line":288},{"level":1,"title":"PART VIII: Social stability and policy design","slug":"part-viii-social-stability-and-policy-design","line":296},{"level":2,"title":"Crime and unrest belong in the risk register","slug":"crime-and-unrest-belong-in-the-risk-register","line":298},{"level":2,"title":"A welfare-aware industrial policy","slug":"a-welfare-aware-industrial-policy","line":310},{"level":2,"title":"The verdict","slug":"the-verdict","line":322},{"level":1,"title":"APPENDIX A: Scenario book","slug":"appendix-a-scenario-book","line":332},{"level":2,"title":"Core assumptions","slug":"core-assumptions","line":334},{"level":2,"title":"Annual real resource base","slug":"annual-real-resource-base","line":350},{"level":2,"title":"Sensitivity: remove the welfare weight","slug":"sensitivity-remove-the-welfare-weight","line":365},{"level":2,"title":"Sensitivity: no credit or scarring","slug":"sensitivity-no-credit-or-scarring","line":371},{"level":1,"title":"APPENDIX B: Evidence map and limitations","slug":"appendix-b-evidence-map-and-limitations","line":377},{"level":2,"title":"What is observed and what is assumed","slug":"what-is-observed-and-what-is-assumed","line":379},{"level":2,"title":"Major limitations","slug":"major-limitations","line":395},{"level":2,"title":"Reproducibility","slug":"reproducibility","line":409},{"level":1,"title":"APPENDIX C: Source ledger","slug":"appendix-c-source-ledger","line":415},{"level":2,"title":"Public finance and programme design","slug":"public-finance-and-programme-design","line":417},{"level":2,"title":"Poverty, hunger and children","slug":"poverty-hunger-and-children","line":424},{"level":2,"title":"Labour and local economic effects","slug":"labour-and-local-economic-effects","line":433},{"level":2,"title":"Reading note","slug":"reading-note","line":440}]},"claims":[{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:C01","local_id":"C01","claim":"Withholding the SRD envelope has a central explicit welfare cost of R426.9 billion in welfare-equivalent 2026 rand, about R1.68 of social cost for every R1 withheld. The scenario range is R237 billion to R743 billion.","claim_type":"conditional","status":"conditional","evidence_status":"modelled","confidence":null,"depends_on":["GSX:SRD-002:A01","GSX:SRD-002:A02","GSX:SRD-002:A03"],"result":"GSX:SRD-002:R01","results":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"sensitivity":"high","main_limitation":"This is not a Treasury invoice, a forecast or a confidence interval. Crime, unrest and household dissolution are left outside the priced total. The central case is an analytical benchmark.","source_study":"GSX:SRD-002","version":"1.0","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/claims/C01","supported_by":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"],"contradicted_by":[],"qualifies":[],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:C02","local_id":"C02","claim":"The average industrial outcome in the companion paper does not clear this central welfare hurdle. Only an exceptionally well-executed industrial programme clearly beats it, and the later beneficiaries are not automatically the households who gave up the grant.","claim_type":"conditional","status":"conditional","evidence_status":"modelled","confidence":null,"depends_on":["GSX:SRD-002:A01","GSX:SRD-002:A02"],"result":"GSX:SRD-002:R01","results":["GSX:SRD-002:R01","GSX:SRD-002:R02"],"sensitivity":"high","main_limitation":"The comparison is between a public asset and a social cost. It does not say that cash transfers are always better than investment.","source_study":"GSX:SRD-002","version":"1.0","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/claims/C02","supported_by":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"],"contradicted_by":[],"qualifies":[],"contradicts":[]}],"assumptions":[{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:A01","local_id":"A01","name":"Same envelope","statement":"The withheld resource is about R253.5 billion in constant 2026 purchasing power, the same base as the industrial-fund paper.","value":"253.5","unit":"billion constant 2026 rand","type":"model assumption","provenance":"Manuscript headline ledger","evidence_strength":"shared counterfactual base","sensitivity":"moderate","alternatives":["A different programme window"],"href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/assumptions/A01"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:A02","local_id":"A02","name":"Distributional weights","statement":"In the conservative, central and severe cases, R1 of consumption at the recipient margin is valued at R1.10, R1.50 and R2.00. The weights are normative assumptions.","value":"1.50","unit":"welfare rand per consumption rand, central case","type":"model assumption","provenance":"Manuscript Part I","evidence_strength":"normative assumption","sensitivity":"high","alternatives":["Equal weights","A higher hunger weight"],"href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/assumptions/A02"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:A03","local_id":"A03","name":"No double-counting of local spending","statement":"The local spending multiplier is reported separately and is not added into the welfare cost.","value":"qualitative","unit":"not a scalar","type":"model assumption","provenance":"Manuscript Part I","evidence_strength":"accounting rule","sensitivity":"moderate","alternatives":["Adding the multiplier into the welfare total"],"href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/assumptions/A03"}],"results":[{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:R01","local_id":"R01","statement":"The explicit welfare-equivalent cost of withholding the envelope is between R237 billion and R743 billion. The central estimate is R426.9 billion, about R1.68 of social cost for every R1 withheld.","value":"426.9","unit":"billion welfare-equivalent 2026 rand, central estimate","scenario":"Central welfare case","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/results/R01"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:R02","local_id":"R02","statement":"Additional poverty exposure across the scenarios is 2.5 million to 11.0 million person-years.","value":"2.5","unit":"million person-years, low end of the scenario range","scenario":"Seven-year poverty exposure range","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/results/R02"}],"models":[{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:M01","local_id":"M01","name":"Welfare-cost ledger","statement":"The model prices the explicit welfare cost of withholding the same SRD envelope valued in the industrial-fund paper. It combines consumption, costly credit, scarring and labour effects and keeps the local spending multiplier out of the welfare total.","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/models/M01"}],"sources":[{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:PDF","type":"manuscript","title":"The Welfare Cost of Not Paying the Grant","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant.pdf","author_or_publisher":"GreyScienx","date":"2026-09-27","locator":"27 pages; 1.44 MB","note":"Published manuscript used for this semantic-twin extraction. External references remain represented in the manuscript unless separately registered.","supports":["GSX:SRD-002:C01"],"contradicts":[],"pages":27,"size":"1.44 MB","media_type":"application/pdf"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC01","type":"web_reference","title":"Statistics South Africa, National Poverty Lines 2026","href":"https://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P03101/P031012026.pdf","author_or_publisher":"statssa.gov.za","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC02","type":"web_reference","title":"Statistics South Africa, Poverty Trends in South Africa 2023","href":"https://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/Report-03-10-06/Report-03-10-062023.pdf","author_or_publisher":"statssa.gov.za","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC03","type":"web_reference","title":"Department of Social Development, Rapid Assessment of the SRD Grant","href":"https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_documents/Final%20Special%20COVID19%20SRD%20Grant%20Report.pdf","author_or_publisher":"gov.za","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC04","type":"web_reference","title":"Agence Française de Développement, Local Economic Development Effects of Income Transfers","href":"https://www.afd.fr/sites/afd/files/2023-05-04-18-29/The-local-economic-development-effects-of-income-transfers-in-South-Africa.pdf","author_or_publisher":"afd.fr","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC05","type":"web_reference","title":"Bassier, Budlender and Goldman, Social Protection During South Africa's National Lockdown","href":"https://sa-tied-archive.wider.unu.edu/sites/default/files/SA-TIED-WP210.pdf","author_or_publisher":"sa-tied-archive.wider.unu.edu","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC06","type":"web_reference","title":"NIDS-CRAM, Hunger in South Africa","href":"https://cramsurvey.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/11.-Van-der-Berg-S.-Patel-L.-_-Bridgman-G.-2021-Hunger-in-South-Africa-Results-from-Wave-4-of-NIDS-CRAM.pdf","author_or_publisher":"cramsurvey.org","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC07","type":"web_reference","title":"NIDS-CRAM reports","href":"https://cramsurvey.org/reports/","author_or_publisher":"cramsurvey.org","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC08","type":"web_reference","title":"Statistics South Africa, Child Poverty in South Africa 2026","href":"https://www.statssa.gov.za/?p=19395","author_or_publisher":"statssa.gov.za","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC09","type":"web_reference","title":"Köhler and Bhorat, Can Cash Transfers Aid Labour Market Recovery?","href":"https://africaportal.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/DPRU_WP_202108.pdf","author_or_publisher":"africaportal.org","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC10","type":"web_reference","title":"Bhorat, Köhler and de Villiers, Can a Poverty-Targeted Social Protection Programme Improve Labour Market Outcomes?","href":"https://www.afd.fr/sites/default/files/2023-03-02-12-20/Cash-Transfers-to-the-Unemployed_Economic-Activity_South-Africa.pdf","author_or_publisher":"afd.fr","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC11","type":"web_reference","title":"Public Service Commission, Assessment of COVID-19 Mitigating Mechanisms (2022 report archive)","href":"https://www.psc.gov.za/Resource-Center","author_or_publisher":"psc.gov.za","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC12","type":"web_reference","title":"National Treasury, 2026 Budget Review","href":"https://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/National%20Budget/2026/review/FullBR.pdf","author_or_publisher":"treasury.gov.za","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC13","type":"web_reference","title":"National Treasury, 2026 ENE Vote 19","href":"https://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/National%20Budget/2026/ene/Vote%2019%20Social%20Development.pdf","author_or_publisher":"treasury.gov.za","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC14","type":"web_reference","title":"Parliamentary Budget Office, Pre-budget Brief on the SRD Grant, February 2025","href":"https://www.parliament.gov.za/storage/app/media/PBO/Budget_Analysis/2025/17-02-2025/PBO_pre_budget_brief_on_SRD_Feb_2025.pdf","author_or_publisher":"parliament.gov.za","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC15","type":"web_reference","title":"World Bank, South Africa Social Assistance Programs and Systems Review","href":"https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/398231633427716574/pdf/South-Africa-Social-Assistance-Programs-and-Systems-Review-Policy-Brief.pdf","author_or_publisher":"documents1.worldbank.org","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:SRC16","type":"web_reference","title":"Statistics South Africa, Quarterly Labour Force Survey Q2 2026","href":"https://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P0211/Media%20Release%20QLFS%20Q2%202026.pdf","author_or_publisher":"statssa.gov.za","date":"see cited resource","locator":"URL cited in the manuscript","note":"The manuscript cites this resource. Inclusion does not independently validate it or assign it to a specific claim.","supports":["claim-level support not assigned"],"contradicts":[]}],"datasets":[{"id":"D01","title":"The Welfare Cost of Not Paying the Grant","description":"The published manuscript is the data statement for this form.","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant","geographic_coverage":"South Africa","licence":"The reading copy is published on greyscienx.com. No separate open licence is stated."}],"figures":[{"id":"F01","title":"Welfare cost ledger","caption":"Figure 1. The explicit modelled welfare cost. Values are constant 2026 consumption-equivalent rand, not fiscal expenditure, GDP or a cash compensation bill.","alt_text":"Welfare cost ledger","image_file":"C:/Users/Deriv/Desktop/GreyScienx/research/source/srd-welfare-cost/assets/welfare-ledger.png","data_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model_results.json","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]},{"id":"F02","title":"Grant adequacy","caption":"Figure 2. Monthly grant amounts against the May 2026 national poverty lines. The comparison shows both truths at once: the transfer is inadequate as an income floor and meaningful as marginal cash.","alt_text":"Grant adequacy","image_file":"C:/Users/Deriv/Desktop/GreyScienx/research/source/srd-welfare-cost/assets/grant-adequacy.png","data_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model_results.json","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]},{"id":"F03","title":"Household diffusion","caption":"Figure 3. The payment is individual; the budget is often collective. The household-size and pooling statistics are separate survey findings that together explain why recipient counts understate the population exposed to withdrawal.","alt_text":"Household diffusion","image_file":"C:/Users/Deriv/Desktop/GreyScienx/research/source/srd-welfare-cost/assets/household-diffusion.png","data_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model_results.json","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]},{"id":"F04","title":"Consumption and local activity","caption":"Figure 4. Direct household spending and the larger gross activity it may support. The second bar includes the first and is not added again in the welfare total.","alt_text":"Consumption and local activity","image_file":"C:/Users/Deriv/Desktop/GreyScienx/research/source/srd-welfare-cost/assets/consumption-and-local-activity.png","data_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model_results.json","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]},{"id":"F05","title":"Poverty scenarios","caption":"Figure 5. Only the first two years are anchored to the published pandemic-era range. Later years are explicit scenarios, not measured effects.","alt_text":"Poverty scenarios","image_file":"C:/Users/Deriv/Desktop/GreyScienx/research/source/srd-welfare-cost/assets/poverty-scenarios.png","data_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model_results.json","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]},{"id":"F06","title":"Central cost timeline","caption":"Figure 6. The central welfare-equivalent cost allocated across the real annual grant envelope. This timing is approximate, but the asymmetry is fundamental: hardship is immediate while most industrial returns are delayed.","alt_text":"Central cost timeline","image_file":"C:/Users/Deriv/Desktop/GreyScienx/research/source/srd-welfare-cost/assets/central-cost-timeline.png","data_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model_results.json","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]},{"id":"F07","title":"Industrial welfare matrix","caption":"Figure 7. Paper 1 public industrial value less Paper 2 welfare cost. Positive cells mean the industrial value clears the stated hardship scenario before unpriced distributional and social risks.","alt_text":"Industrial welfare matrix","image_file":"C:/Users/Deriv/Desktop/GreyScienx/research/source/srd-welfare-cost/assets/industrial-welfare-matrix.png","data_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model_results.json","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]},{"id":"F08","title":"Jobs compensation","caption":"Figure 8. An illustrative access test, not an employment forecast. Capital per job and the former-recipient capture share are assumptions designed to show that aggregate job creation and compensation are different questions.","alt_text":"Jobs compensation","image_file":"C:/Users/Deriv/Desktop/GreyScienx/research/source/srd-welfare-cost/assets/jobs-compensation.png","data_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model_results.json","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]},{"id":"F09","title":"Social risk ladder","caption":"Figure 9. A plausible escalation sequence, not a prediction. The final stage is deliberately unpriced because rare-event distributions and attribution are too uncertain for a credible central estimate.","alt_text":"Social risk ladder","image_file":"C:/Users/Deriv/Desktop/GreyScienx/research/source/srd-welfare-cost/assets/social-risk-ladder.png","data_file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/model_results.json","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]}],"tables":[{"id":"T00","title":"Tables in the manuscript","description":"Tables remain in the manuscript and are not exported as separate data files.","file":"research/source/srd-welfare-cost/report.md","result_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:R01"],"source_ids":["GSX:SRD-002:PDF"]}],"reproducibility":{"code_available":true,"data_available":true,"environment_available":false,"random_seed":"the published statement does not rely on a recorded random seed","software":["Python 3"],"repository_url":null},"editorial":{"required_checks":{"stable_ids":true,"no_naked_claims":true,"assumptions_linked":true,"results_linked":true,"sources_linked":true,"units_complete":true,"price_years_complete":true,"scenario_labels_complete":true,"figure_data_available":true,"alt_text_complete":true,"text_extraction_verified":true,"pdf_visual_qa_complete":true,"links_checked":true,"reproducibility_checked":true,"ai_disclosure_complete":true,"human_final_review":true},"blocking_issues":[],"warnings":["Reproduction verifies the registered JSON baseline; it is not independent empirical validation of the model.","Publisher-reviewed candidate links are accepted as contextual manuscript references, not as independent empirical validation of modelled outputs.","1 cited external links could not be verified because the server returned a transient error or the request did not complete."],"change_log":[{"version":"1.0","date":"2026-09-29","author":"GreyScienx","summary":"Filled the semantic-twin form from the published manuscript. Empty fields now say what is registered or what is not published.","changed_ids":["GSX:SRD-002"]},{"version":"1.0","date":"2026-09-29","author":"Pakang Senosha","summary":"Recorded publisher final review, PDF visual approval, and acceptance of candidate links as contextual references.","changed_ids":["GSX:SRD-002"]}]},"related_studies":[{"id":"GSX:SRD-001","slug":"the-r350-industrialisation-counterfactual","title":"The R350 Industrialisation Counterfactual","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-r350-industrialisation-counterfactual"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-003","slug":"consumption-today-or-productive-capital-tomorrow","title":"Consumption Today or Productive Capital Tomorrow?","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/consumption-today-or-productive-capital-tomorrow"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-004","slug":"the-public-capital-multiplier","title":"The Public-Capital Multiplier","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-public-capital-multiplier"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-005","slug":"the-r200-billion-factory","title":"The R200 Billion Factory","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-r200-billion-factory"}],"links":{"html":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant","markdown":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/markdown","manuscript":"https://greyscienx.com/api/v1/research/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/manuscript","json":"https://greyscienx.com/api/v1/research/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant","pdf":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant.pdf"},"citation":{"machine":"GreyScienx, GSX:SRD-002, version 1.0","text":"GreyScienx. The Welfare Cost of Not Paying the Grant. GSX:SRD-002. Version 1.0."},"retrieval_note":"The complete source manuscript is available as Markdown. Published claim objects are a claim-led extraction, not an exhaustive list of every statement in the paper. Read each claim with its assumptions and main limitation; the catalog summary is not a finding."}