{"schema_version":"GreyResearchGraph 1.0","study_id":"GSX:SRD-002","node_count":18,"edge_count":26,"nodes":[{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:C01","type":"claim","label":"Withholding the SRD envelope has a central explicit welfare cost of R426.9 billion in welfare-equivalent 2026 rand, about R1.68 of social cost for every R1 withheld. The scenario range is R237 billion to R743 billion.","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/claims/C01"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:A01","type":"assumption","label":"The withheld resource is about R253.5 billion in constant 2026 purchasing power, the same base as the industrial-fund paper.","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/api/v1/research/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:A02","type":"assumption","label":"In the conservative, central and severe cases, R1 of consumption at the recipient margin is valued at R1.10, R1.50 and R2.00. The weights are normative assumptions.","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/api/v1/research/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:A03","type":"assumption","label":"The local spending multiplier is reported separately and is not added into the welfare cost.","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/api/v1/research/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:R01","type":"result","label":"The explicit welfare-equivalent cost of withholding the envelope is between R237 billion and R743 billion. The central estimate is R426.9 billion, about R1.68 of social cost for every R1 withheld.","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/api/v1/research/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:C02","type":"claim","label":"The average industrial outcome in the companion paper does not clear this central welfare hurdle. Only an exceptionally well-executed industrial programme clearly beats it, and the later beneficiaries are not automatically the households who gave up the grant.","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant/claims/C02"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:R02","type":"result","label":"Additional poverty exposure across the scenarios is 2.5 million to 11.0 million person-years.","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/api/v1/research/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-001","type":"study","label":"The R350 Industrialisation Counterfactual","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-r350-industrialisation-counterfactual"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002","type":"study","label":"The Welfare Cost of Not Paying the Grant","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant"},{"id":"GSX:SRD","type":"series","label":"The R350 Counterfactual","evidence_status":null,"href":"https://greyscienx.com/series/r350-counterfactual"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:M01","type":"model","label":"Welfare-cost ledger","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/api/v1/research/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-002:PDF","type":"source","label":"The Welfare Cost of Not Paying the Grant","evidence_status":null,"href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-welfare-cost-of-not-paying-the-grant.pdf"},{"id":"GSX:TOPIC:grants","type":"topic","label":"Social grants","evidence_status":null,"href":"https://greyscienx.com/topics/grants"},{"id":"GSX:TOPIC:fiscal-policy","type":"topic","label":"Fiscal policy","evidence_status":null,"href":"https://greyscienx.com/topics/fiscal-policy"},{"id":"GSX:TOPIC:south-africa","type":"topic","label":"South Africa","evidence_status":null,"href":"https://greyscienx.com/topics/south-africa"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-003","type":"study","label":"Consumption Today or Productive Capital Tomorrow?","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/consumption-today-or-productive-capital-tomorrow"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-004","type":"study","label":"The Public-Capital Multiplier","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-public-capital-multiplier"},{"id":"GSX:SRD-005","type":"study","label":"The R200 Billion Factory","evidence_status":"modelled","href":"https://greyscienx.com/research/r350-counterfactual/the-r200-billion-factory"}],"edges":[{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C01","predicate":"depends_on","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:A01","note":"Registered dependency."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C01","predicate":"depends_on","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:A02","note":"Registered dependency."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C01","predicate":"depends_on","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:A03","note":"Registered dependency."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C01","predicate":"derived_from","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:R01","note":"Registered result."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C02","predicate":"depends_on","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:A01","note":"Registered dependency."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C02","predicate":"depends_on","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:A02","note":"Registered dependency."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C02","predicate":"derived_from","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:R01","note":"Registered result."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C02","predicate":"derived_from","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:R02","note":"Registered result."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-001","predicate":"related_to","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002","note":"The R350 Counterfactual"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"part_of","object_id":"GSX:SRD","note":"The R350 Counterfactual"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"has_claim","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C01","note":"Registered claim."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C01","predicate":"generated_by","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:M01","note":"Welfare-cost ledger"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C01","predicate":"supported_by","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:PDF","note":"Source registered on the conditional claim."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"has_claim","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C02","note":"Registered claim."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C02","predicate":"generated_by","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:M01","note":"Welfare-cost ledger"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002:C02","predicate":"supported_by","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002:PDF","note":"Source registered on the conditional claim."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"has_topic","object_id":"GSX:TOPIC:grants","note":"Registered topic."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"has_topic","object_id":"GSX:TOPIC:fiscal-policy","note":"Registered topic."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"has_topic","object_id":"GSX:TOPIC:south-africa","note":"Registered topic."},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"related_to","object_id":"GSX:SRD-001","note":"The R350 Counterfactual"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"related_to","object_id":"GSX:SRD-003","note":"The R350 Counterfactual"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"related_to","object_id":"GSX:SRD-004","note":"The R350 Counterfactual"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-002","predicate":"related_to","object_id":"GSX:SRD-005","note":"The R350 Counterfactual"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-003","predicate":"related_to","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002","note":"The R350 Counterfactual"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-004","predicate":"related_to","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002","note":"The R350 Counterfactual"},{"subject_id":"GSX:SRD-005","predicate":"related_to","object_id":"GSX:SRD-002","note":"The R350 Counterfactual"}]}